Navigating the Crossroads: Integrating Christian Process Thought and Zen Buddhism
Sophia: Sophia is a twenty-six-year-old social worker from Pittsburgh who works with children. She seeks balance and centeredness in her life and wants to help change the world while being present in each moment in a relaxed and compassionate way. Sophia is drawn to both Zen Buddhism and Christianity and senses that process philosophy might serve as a bridge between the two. She is a regular reader of Open Horizons, drawn to its pages on Christian and Buddhist process philosophy. She is unsure about the concept of "God."
Professor Elizabeth Blake: She is a fifty-two-year-old professor teaching Women's Studies and World Religions at a large university in Wisconsin. She is a Whitehead scholar, knowledgeable about Whiteheadian understandings of both Buddhism and Christianity. Elizabeth is sensitive to the ways Christianity and Zen can help guide a meaningful life. She wrote her PhD dissertation on Whitehead and Eschatology, and is now active in a local Buddhist sangha and Episcopal Church.
Both are fictional. Their correspondence is imagined by OpenAI as prompted by Jay McDaniel.
Dear Professor Blake,
I hope this letter finds you well. My name is Julia, and I am at a crossroads in my spiritual journey. I have been deeply moved by the insights of process philosophy, and I find myself drawn to both the Christian and Zen interpretations of this worldview. If you aren't familiar with Process Zen, you might find this page in Open Horizons helpful. It's called Process Zen: Being Present in the Moment.
As someone who is new to these paths, I am writing to you for guidance in making a decision about which direction to take.
Growing up in a Christian household, I was taught to seek God’s presence in my life and to aspire to live according to His will. The teachings of Christian process thinkers resonate with me, particularly the emphasis on adventure and the pursuit of ethical possibilities. The idea of living each moment as an opportunity to co-create with God and bring about positive change in the world fills me with hope and excitement. It feels like a call to action, to participate in a larger story of redemption and transformation.
On the other hand, I have also been exploring Zen Buddhism, and its process-oriented approach has captivated me as well. The Zen emphasis on mindfulness and living fully in the present moment offers a profound sense of peace and clarity. It also helps me be present to the people I work with. I am a social worker. Practices like zazen have helped me to quiet my mind and become more attuned to the here and now. The simplicity and directness of Zen appeal to me, offering a way to experience the depth of life without the distractions of past regrets or future anxieties.
I find myself torn between these two paths. The Christian process way offers an adventurous spirit, encouraging me to look forward and embrace new possibilities. It aligns with my desire to make a difference in the world and to live out my faith in tangible ways. However, the Zen process way calls me to deepen my awareness of the present, to find wisdom and insight in each moment. It promises a sense of inner calm and a way to navigate life with grace and presence.
I wonder if there is a way to integrate both of these approaches in a harmonious manner. Can one live with an adventurous spirit while also being deeply present in each moment? Is it possible to pursue ethical possibilities for the future without losing sight of the beauty and truth of the present?
I am seeking your advice on how to navigate this decision. As a process philosopher, how do you see the relationship between these two paths? Can they complement each other, or must one choose between them? I would greatly appreciate any insights or suggestions you might have to offer.
Thank you for taking the time to read my letter. I look forward to your response and hope that it will help me find clarity and direction in my spiritual journey.
Warm regards,
Sophia
*
Dear Sophia,
Thank you for your heartfelt letter. It is always encouraging to hear from individuals who are exploring the depths of their spiritual journey with such openness and sincerity. Your reflections on the Christian and Zen process ways are insightful, and I appreciate the thoughtful consideration you are giving to each path.
The dilemma you face is a profound one, and it speaks to the richness of process philosophy that it can embrace such diverse yet complementary approaches to life and spirituality. Let me offer some thoughts that might help you find your way.
First, it is important to recognize that both the Christian and Zen process ways are rooted in a shared cosmology of interconnectedness and becoming. This common ground can provide a foundation for integrating aspects of both traditions in a way that is meaningful to you.
The Christian process way, with its emphasis on adventure and ethical possibilities, encourages a proactive engagement with the world. It invites you to participate in the ongoing creation of a better future, guided by a vision of the good that is always luring us forward. This approach resonates with the dynamic nature of process philosophy, which sees the universe as a continuous unfolding of new potentials.
On the other hand, the Zen process way, with its focus on mindfulness and presence, offers a different but equally valuable perspective. It teaches us to find depth and meaning in the present moment, to experience life as it is, without the distractions of the past or future. This present-centeredness can enrich your life with a sense of peace and clarity, grounding you in the here and now.
You ask if it is possible to integrate these two approaches, and I believe the answer is yes. In fact, many find that these paths can complement each other beautifully. Consider this: the adventurous spirit of the Christian process way can be tempered by the mindfulness of Zen, leading to a balanced approach that is both forward-looking and deeply rooted in the present. You can aspire to ethical action and transformation while also cultivating an awareness and appreciation for each moment as it unfolds.
In practical terms, this might mean incorporating practices from both traditions into your daily life. You could engage in mindful meditation to center yourself and develop a keen awareness of the present, while also setting intentions and goals that align with your vision for a better future. By doing so, you create a dynamic interplay between action and presence, between striving for what could be and fully experiencing what is.
Remember, there is no need to rush this decision or to force a resolution. Allow yourself the time and space to explore both paths, to experience their teachings and practices, and to see how they resonate with you over time. Your journey is unique, and the way you integrate these insights will be uniquely yours.
I hope these reflections provide some clarity and encouragement as you continue your journey. Trust in your own inner wisdom, and know that the path you choose, or the way you weave these paths together, will be a beautiful expression of your own spiritual quest.
Warm regards,
Professor Blake
*
Dear Professor Blake,
I have another question. As you know, most Zen Buddhists do not talk about God. Their emphasis is on self-power, not other-power. By contrast, Pure Land Buddhists do talk about something like God. They speak of Amida Buddha as a cosmic Bodhisattva of compassion, which sounds a lot like a process understanding of God: all-loving but not all-powerful, reaching out with loving lures, and absorbing the world's sufferings. I know that some Christian process theologians—Jay McDaniel and John Cobb, for example—agree. John Cobb has even written a book saying that Pure Land Buddhists can recognize Amida as the living presence of God, and Christians can recognize God as the living presence of Amida.
But I myself am not sure about God, including Whitehead's God. Sometimes it makes sense and sometimes it doesn't. If I incorporate insights and practices from both Christian process and Zen process, must I make up my mind?
Warm regards,
Sophia *
Dear Sophia,
Thank you for your thoughtful follow-up question. You're right. The relationship between Zen and Pure Land Buddhism, and the varying conceptions of divinity within these traditions, is indeed a fascinating and complex topic.
Zen Buddhism’s focus on self-power, or jiriki, emphasizes personal effort and direct experience in the pursuit of enlightenment. This tradition tends to avoid metaphysical discussions about God or deities, instead directing practitioners to look inward and realize their own Buddha nature through practices like meditation and mindfulness. In contrast, Pure Land Buddhism emphasizes other-power, or tariki, particularly through devotion to Amida Buddha. Amida Buddha is viewed as a cosmic Bodhisattva of compassion who vows to save all beings, and this does bear resemblance to certain process theological views of God. In process thought, God is seen as an all-loving presence, not omnipotent in the classical sense but rather working through persuasive, loving lures to guide creation toward greater harmony and beauty.
Your question about whether you must make up your mind about God when integrating insights and practices from both Christian process and Zen process is an important one. The answer, I believe, lies in the very nature of process philosophy itself, which values openness, ongoing inquiry, and the evolution of thought and belief.
Process philosophy encourages us to embrace a stance of openness and flexibility, recognizing that our understanding of the divine and ultimate reality can grow and change over time. You do not need to have a fixed, final answer about God in order to benefit from the practices and insights of both traditions. Instead, you can approach this question with a sense of curiosity and willingness to explore, allowing your experiences and reflections to shape your understanding as you go.
Incorporating practices from Christian process and Zen process can enrich your spiritual journey without requiring you to settle on a definitive concept of God. You might find value in the Christian process emphasis on co-creating with a loving presence, while also appreciating the Zen focus on direct experience and mindfulness. These practices can coexist in your life, providing a holistic approach that honors both action and contemplation, future possibilities and present realities.
If you find inspiration in the compassionate figure of Amida Buddha from Pure Land Buddhism, you might also draw parallels with process theology’s view of God as a loving, guiding presence. This can serve as a bridge between your explorations of self-power and other-power, allowing you to navigate the spiritual landscape with both humility and empowerment.
Ultimately, your spiritual path is a deeply personal one, and it is perfectly okay to live with questions and uncertainties. The journey itself, with its moments of clarity and mystery, is a valuable part of your growth and discovery.
I hope this perspective helps you feel more at ease with your explorations. Trust in your own inner wisdom and allow yourself the freedom to evolve in your understanding of the divine. Your openness and willingness to engage with diverse spiritual traditions are strengths that will guide you well on your path.