Becoming a Pocket of Grace

Collecting Light and Creating Light
in a Vain and Transactional World​
​

An Unkind Man

His world has no space for kindness or love. He sees relationships as mere instruments for his own advancement, tools to be manipulated, discarded, or destroyed at will. At his core is a deep cynicism about human nature. He does not believe in sincerity or virtue; he assumes that everyone is just as self-serving and deceitful as he is, though perhaps less skillful at disguising it. He has no grand ideology, no ultimate goal beyond the pleasure of manipulation and the thrill of control. His worldview is a dark mirror, revealing what happens when all human connection is reduced to a cynical game of power and deception.

The Master Puppeteer

I am talking, of course, about Iago in Shakespeare's play Othello. Iago moves through Othello like a master puppeteer, skillfully orchestrating the downfall of those around him with a calculated precision that borders on artistry. His ability to manipulate stems from his profound understanding of human psychology—he preys on Othello’s insecurities, Roderigo’s desperation, Cassio’s ambition, and Desdemona’s innocence, twisting their virtues into weapons against them.

In reducing human relationships to mere transactions, Iago strips them of their meaning, treating love as a delusion and trust as a weakness. He exposes the fragility of bonds built on faith and devotion, showing how easily they can be shattered by suspicion and deceit.

Iago's Dilemma: The Price of a Transactional World

Yet, in doing so, he ultimately exposes himself. Unlike Othello, who experiences profound grief and remorse, Iago ends the play in lifeless silence, his machinations collapsing around him. His final fate—a condemned man without allies, without love, and without purpose—suggests that while his philosophy can wreak devastation, it cannot create anything lasting. He is a dark void, consuming all that surrounds him but leaving nothing in its place.
​
He suffers what might be called the villain’s dilemma: the very worldview that enables his power ensures his ultimate isolation. Iago may believe he holds all the strings, but by the end, he is left with nothing—no allies, no love, no future. He is the architect of his own emptiness, proving that a life without genuine connection, without trust, is not power, but a prison.

Architect or Mirror? Iago and the World That Made Him

But we must also ask—is Iago truly the architect of his own emptiness? Or is he, in some sense, a product of a world that already operates according to the transactional logic he so masterfully exploits?

Shakespeare gives us no backstory for Iago, no clear psychological wound or external force that shaped his worldview. Unlike other villains in literature who are forged by betrayal, trauma, or ideology, Iago seems to emerge fully formed—a cynic, a manipulator, a man who sees love and trust as mere illusions. This raises unsettling questions: Did Iago choose to see the world this way, or did the world teach him that relationships are always transactions, that power is the only currency that matters?

Venice, as depicted in Othello, was a hub of global commerce, a city where wealth, reputation, and influence were fluid and often dictated by economic success. In many ways, it was one of the first truly capitalist societies, driven by trade, financial transactions, and mercantile ambition. Power was tied to wealth, and social standing was often precarious, requiring constant negotiation and strategic maneuvering. In such a world, trust was fragile, and loyalty was frequently subordinate to profit and position.

It is not difficult to imagine how this environment might have reinforced Iago’s worldview. In a society where success depended on calculated self-interest, where alliances could shift like markets, and where men could be undone by a single misstep, his ruthless pragmatism may not have been an aberration but an adaptation. If the economy of Venice rewarded those who could outmaneuver others, perhaps Iago’s tragedy is not simply his own moral failing but the inevitable result of a society that prioritized gain over grace, power over principle, and advantage over affection.

By exploring Iago’s transactional logic in light of the economic forces shaping Venetian society, we are forced to ask an even more uncomfortable question: If he was merely playing the game as it was designed, is he truly the villain—or merely the one most willing to admit the rules?

Pockets of Grace: Resisting Transactionalism in Daily Life

Yet even in a world dominated by power and transactional relationships, pockets of grace emerge. These moments of generosity, love, and trust appear in small, often unexpected ways—proof that the world is not entirely lost to Iago’s logic.

• A teacher who stays after school to mentor a struggling student, not because they’re paid extra, but because they care.
• A neighbor who helps another in need, expecting nothing in return.
• Community volunteers who dedicate their time to food banks, shelters, and crisis centers, driven by a sense of shared humanity rather than personal reward.
• Friendships where trust is given freely, not as a strategic calculation but as an act of faith.

These acts of self-giving resist the notion that all relationships are transactions. They are reminders that human beings are capable of more than competition and self-interest—we are capable of solidarity, compassion, and love.

The World as It Should Be and Could Be

If Iago’s worldview represents a transactional world at its most extreme—a world where every relationship is a means to an end, where trust is weakness, and where power is the only true currency—then what is the alternative? What is the world as it should be?

From a Christian perspective, relationships are not meant to be transactions but gifts. Love, trust, and friendship are not tools for personal gain but sacred encounters in which the dignity of the other is honored, not exploited.

This is the world that Jesus envisioned—a world where power is found in humility, where the last shall be first, where love is stronger than deception. In contrast to Iago’s manipulative cunning, Christian love is not about control but about self-giving. Jesus tells his disciples: “Greater love has no one than this, that he lay down his life for his friends” (John 15:13).

Love, in this vision, is not a contract but a covenant, not a strategy but a calling. This is the challenge before us today: to choose whether we will continue down the path of transactionalism or whether we will embrace the deeper, richer alternative—a culture of trust, of mutual care, of grace freely given.

Choosing a Different Path

Iago’s downfall is not just his own tragedy—it is a warning. A world that follows his logic, where every bond is transactional and every relationship is a game of advantage, is a world that ultimately devours itself. But the alternative is already here, waiting to be embraced.

We must cultivate the pockets of grace that exist in our communities, in our friendships, in our acts of service. We must resist the urge to see relationships as mere transactions and instead recognize them as gifts.

Shakespeare’s Othello shows us the consequences of a world ruled by Iago’s logic. The Christian gospel—and the best parts of our humanity—show us what can take its place.

In 1 Corinthians 12:31, Paul speaks of a “still more excellent way” beyond power and self-interest—a way defined not by manipulation but by love.

This love is not a bargain; it is not a strategy; it is not a transaction. It is a gift. And it is the only way to break free from the prison of self-interest that Iago—and our world—so often mistake for power. The world as it is does not have to be the world as it will be. There is a still more excellent way. 

We do not become pockets of grace alone. We grow into them in community with others who seek the same, as in a local congregation or shared space of care. We recognize that our own lives are in process, always evolving, always unfinished, always open to new possibilities for love and healing.

We trust that God—whatever else God is—is about grace, not transaction. And God’s own life is a pocket of grace, a wide one indeed—a well into which our lives, and all lives, flow.

​God is the deep source from which all grace arises, the one who holds the pain of the world without demand, who offers fresh possibilities without coercion, who loves without condition.

The process of becoming a pocket grace begins, for individuals and communities, by collecting the scraps of light that already exist in the world, despite the vanity and the transactional spirit, It will take each scrap of light, every day, to help us mend the world.

​

Collecting Light

by Deborah Cooper

I see the way the chickadees
take turns at the feeder.
I watch a neighbor take
her husband’s hand.
 
I see the way the sun will find
the only interruption
in dark clouds
to toss this amber light
across the pines.
 
I see a row of cars
stop on the road
until the orange cat
has safely crossed,
then take off slowly, should
she change her mind.
 
I watch the way my brother
lifts our mother from
the wheelchair
to the car,
the shawl he lays
across her lap.
 
I save up every scrap
of light,
because I know that it will take
each tiny consolation
every day
to mend the world.