When I watched the flood sweep away everyone I loved, I heard someone say, “Ah, but it is all God godding.”
He told me he was a mystic and that everything is an emanation of God, the ultimate reality. The river, the flood, the terror, the deaths, and the grief—all of it was God pouring forth into the world.
I thought to myself: So much the less for ultimate reality. I am looking for Cosmic Love. I am looking for a Love that is present in the suffering but does not cause it; a Love that feels the loss, receives those who are lost, and beckons the living toward courage, compassion, and healing.
Perhaps the flood emanates from Creativity—the wild, morally ambiguous power by which things come into being and pass away. But the hands reaching into the water, the strangers rescuing strangers, the grieving comforting one another, and the long work of rebuilding: these may be emanations of Cosmic Love. Everything may emanate from Creativity, but not everything emanates from God.
- Jay McDaniel/ChatGPT
Two Ultimates: Creativity and Cosmic Love
Ontological and Axiological Emanation in a Whiteheadian Perspective
Jay McDaniel 8/27/2026
In what follows, I use the word “God” to name Cosmic Love: the living Whole of the universe in which we live and move and have our being, who cares for each and all with tender care, and the Mind of the universe from which, moment by moment, we receive energizing possibilities for renewal, compassion, zest, and peace. These two realities, the living Whole and the divine Mind, are not different. Together they form Cosmic Love, tender and transformational.
God, understood in this way, is not the ultimate reality from which every event emerges. God is not the ground of existence, not the ground of being. That ultimate reality is Creativity. Things can emanate from God axiologically insofar as, through their own self-creativity, they embody and help realize the divine aims for the universe. They do not, however, emanate from God ontologically. They are ontological emanations of Creativity, which is itself neither good nor evil, but the groundless ground of all that is.
In human life this Creativity is our freedom. In the more than human world it is the internal spontaneity of each and every actual entity anywhere in the universe. There is Creativity in the dynamics of a living cell, the spontaneity of an atomic event in the depths of an atom, the evolution of life on distant planets, and the collisions of galaxies. Creativity is not "good" in a moral sense, but it is powerful and awe-evocative.
A full religious life can include both ultimates: Creativity as the ultimate reality and God as the ultimate actuality. Cosmic Love is a manifestation of Creativity, but not the only manifestation.
Ontological and Axiological Emanation
One of the fundamental features of a mystical sensibility, found in traditions in the West and in other parts of the world, is the idea that the universe is a manifestation or expression of an ultimate reality.
In Abrahamic traditions, this ultimate reality has often—wrongly, I think—been identified as God. The metaphysical ultimate of Greek philosophy, the Being of beings, was identified with the divinity of biblical sensibilities, Adonia or Abba. Whitehead disagreed. He called the ontological ultimate Creativity (his version of the Being of beings) and distinguished it from God, its primordial but not exclusive embodiment.
If this distinction is not made, God is called “the ultimate reality,” and this idea is often conjoined with emanationist sensibilities. God then creates the universe out of Godself, which means that everything we see around us—and we ourselves—are instances of God godding. This would mean that all things good and beautiful are God godding, but also that all things violent, hateful, and unjust are God godding.
A Whiteheadian approach avoids this problem by distinguishing between ontological emanation and axiological emanation and affirming both kinds. Understood in terms of emanation, the distinction is not Whitehead’s own; he never speaks of emanation at all. But it offers a way of bringing Whitehead's philosophy into conversation with people of an 'emantationist' orientation. I count myself among them.
Ontological Emanation: Emerging from the Creative Abyss
Ontological emanation is the self-creativity of each finite occasion of experience. In the immediacy of its becoming, every occasion receives influences from its past and creates from them a new and unrepeatable unity. This is the activity by which, in Whitehead’s words, “the many become one and are increased by one.”
This act of self-creation cannot be reduced to the activity of another finite occasion or even to that of a divine creator. It arises de novo in the immediacy of the moment and manifests an ultimate principle: Creativity itself. Creativity is the spontaneous activity expressed in every act of becoming.
There will be more instances of Creativity in the future than there are in the present, which means that some instances of Creativity are, at present, not yet manifest. This leads to the idea that we can speak of Creativity as manifest and Creativity as unmanifest. In itself, Creativity is akin to the neutral “stuff” of which all things are made, except that it is devoid of the connotation of passivity. It cannot be characterized apart from the self-creative entities that embody it. It is thus a creative abyss of which all things are localized manifestations.
Ontological emanation is the perpetual emergence of entities from this creative abyss, which is the ontological or metaphysical ground of all that exists. It is “the ultimate reality,” but it is not a thing among things. It is more like a no-thingness than a something. Cosmic Love is its ultimate and primordial expression, but not its only expression. Every finite occasion is also an expression of Creativity.
Ontological emanation can unfold in ways that are beautiful or horrible, constructive or destructive. Every event is an ontological emanation of Creativity, but not every event is an emanation of God understood as Cosmic Love.
Axiological Emanation: Emerging from Cosmic Love
Cosmic Love is the living Whole of the universe and the Mind of the universe. As the living Whole, it feels and includes the experiences of all finite beings, gathering them into its own ongoing life with tender care and particularized love. It is like a cosmic bodhisattva in Buddhism.
As the Mind of the universe, Cosmic Love envisages pure possibilities and provides each finite occasion with an initial aim: a lure toward the best form of well-being available in its particular situation. This lure does not determine what the occasion will become. The creature may embody the possibility, modify it, neglect it, distort it, or resist it. The lure of God within a creature is a divine Eros—an Eros that belongs both to God and to the creature.
Axiological emanation occurs when a creature responds constructively to this initial aim and brings something of its value into actuality. What emanates from Cosmic Love is therefore not the self-creativity of the creature itself. In this sense, it is not the “being” of the creature. What emanates is an aim—a possibility for beauty, intensity, harmony, goodness, or love—which the creature freely embodies. The creature thus becomes an instance of God godding.
Unlike ontological emanation, axiological emanation does not occur in every instance. Everything that happens manifests Creativity, but only some events embody the possibilities offered by Cosmic Love.
Aesthetic Emanation
Axiological emanation can take at least two forms. The first is aesthetic emanation. Aesthetic emanation occurs when finite existents actualize possibilities for beauty, intensity, harmony, contrast, complexity, and ordered novelty. We see it in atomic and molecular structures, stars and galaxies, living cells and organisms, ecosystems and animal experience. We also see it in human music, visual art, architecture, ritual, and poetry.
This form of emanation is nonmoral, but it is not immoral. A galaxy, a living cell, or a musical pattern is not morally virtuous, but it can nevertheless embody genuine value. Its beauty and intensity can be understood as finite actualizations of possibilities offered by Cosmic Love.
Moral Emanation
The second form is moral emanation. It occurs when beings capable of moral responsibility actualize possibilities for compassion, justice, courage, forgiveness, fidelity, and care.
Moral emanation belongs especially, though perhaps not exclusively, to human life. It occurs whenever a person responds to the divine Eros by becoming more fully awake and alive in loving ways. Such a response adds something to the universe that did not exist before. It also adds to the experience and satisfaction of Cosmic Love. We do not merely receive Cosmic Love; we help complete it. In Whiteheadian language, we help “God” become “more God.”
Moral and aesthetic emanation can overlap without being identical. An act of compassion can possess both moral and aesthetic value because it brings contrasting interests into a richer harmony. The spiral structure of a galaxy, by contrast, may possess aesthetic value without possessing moral value. Something can also be aesthetically powerful while remaining morally destructive. Intensity alone is not goodness.
Unfinished Emanation
This distinction allows us to say that the universe is an emanation of God, but only in a qualified sense.
The universe is wholly an ontological emanation of Creativity. Every event embodies the spontaneous self-creativity by which new realities come into existence. The universe is an axiological emanation of Cosmic Love only where creatures actualize the valuable possibilities offered to them.
The universe is therefore not a finished product flowing necessarily from a perfect source. It is an unfinished and uneven response to divine possibility. Its beauty and goodness emerge through cooperation between Cosmic Love and creaturely self-creativity; its tragedy and destructiveness emerge when creaturely creativity falls short of, distorts, or resists the divine aim.
Everything is an expression of Creativity, but not everything is an expression of Cosmic Love. The evolving universe becomes an emanation of God wherever its many forms of self-creativity embody beauty, harmony, goodness, and love.