— The Levin Lab, “Frequently Asked Questions,” “What are some of these unusual terms you use?” entry on “Selflet,” drmichaellevin.org/resources. Accessed October 28, 2026. Latest Version. Undelining Mine.
- Goal - A goal exists whenever using the tools of goal-based frameworks (e.g., cybernetics) give engineers good traction on the system (prediction and control).
- This is not the same thing as “purpose” (high-level goals where an agent has the meta-cognition to think about having goals and what they might be). And, I think even bowling balls and such have the tiniest, most basic, nano-goals because they follow least-action laws.
- The word “goal” is useful to indicate situations where an engineer does not need to micromanage some aspects of the system because they can offload that onto the system itself (when it has some ability to pursue goals without you controlling each step).
- A goal-directed system lets you, as the engineer, trust it to do stuff when you’re not around. So, does a bowling ball have such a property? Yes. Imagine you’re an engineer building a Roller Coaster at an amusement park. What you have to do is engineer a way for it to get up the hill. But you don’t have to worry about getting it down the hill - it already does that, autonomously.
- Following energy gradients is the simplest, most basic goal there is, and thus it’s not 0 on the scale of goal-directedness. Sure, it’s incredibly minimal and doesn’t quite look like the goals smart beings have (although some human psychological phenomena can be cashed out as a system following an energy landscape in terms of basic drives and rewards etc.), but I think it’s not 0.
- Crucially, thinking of goals this way (as a continuum) avoids pseudoproblems brought on by binary frameworks, such as the following. Do single cell organisms have goals? If so, then little bags of chemical networks have goals. If not, then given that we all formed from single cells (fertilized egg), when during the gradual, extended process of development, did goal-directedness show up?
-