When Your Neighbor
is a Christian Nationalist
A Process-Relational Approach
Jay McDaniel
Sources and Approach
Shortly I will tell you a little about two neighbors of mine: Greg and Alice. Greg is a Christian nationalist and Alice is a United Methodist. Greg lives two doors to my right and Alice lives two doors to my left. I like them both, but I don't like Greg's Christian nationalism. I am a Methodist like Alice. We believe in a God who transcends national boundaries and includes all. We worry about the consequences of Christian nationalism: its misogyny, its violence, its disdain for 'outsiders,' its treatment of immigrants, its authoritarianism. We see it as a threat. Still, Alice and I both like Greg. He doesn't seem evil to us. He seems kind.
My subject, then, is Christian nationalism—why people like Greg embrace it and how people like Alice (and like me) might respond critically but lovingly, with an emphasis on relationships not shaming. In many circles that I inhabit, almost all "liberal" by Greg's definition, Christian nationalism is evil, pure and simple, and any hint of love, even for people who embrace it, is out of the question. It can seem blasphemous to say anything nice about a Christian nationalist. It is as evil to us "liberals" as is liberalism to many people like Greg. But as a Christian I just can't see shutting out people. If God loves everybody, God loves Greg, too, and I should do the same. It's not hard. Like I said, he's a kind man.
So what is Christian nationalism? Here I follow the lead of Nilay Saiya, Associate Professor of Public Policy and Global Affairs at Nanyang Technological University in Singapore. I include a talk given by him below, given at Harvard University, in conversation with David N. Hempton, Harvard University Distinguished Service Professor and Alonzo L. McDonald Family Professor of Evangelical Theological Studies.
Saiya, a scholar of religion and global politics, is the author of Weapon of Peace: How Religious Liberty Combats Terrorism (Cambridge University Press, 2018) and The Global Politics of Jesus: A Christian Case for Church-State Separation (Oxford University Press, 2022). His research, along with the broader academic literature on Christian nationalism, informs the definitions, descriptions, and analyses that follow.
Underlying my approach is a theological presupposition true to the spirit of process theology: God is a God of love, dwelling in all hearts as an inwardly felt lure to love and care for others, to create communities of care, and to leave no one out. Like other process theologians, I don't think the future is known in advance by God, and that today there are various possibilities for how the world unfolds. I'm hoping for a world that Alice would like, and that is revealed, politics aside, in the kindness of Greg.
Shortly I will tell you a little about two neighbors of mine: Greg and Alice. Greg is a Christian nationalist and Alice is a United Methodist. Greg lives two doors to my right and Alice lives two doors to my left. I like them both, but I don't like Greg's Christian nationalism. I am a Methodist like Alice. We believe in a God who transcends national boundaries and includes all. We worry about the consequences of Christian nationalism: its misogyny, its violence, its disdain for 'outsiders,' its treatment of immigrants, its authoritarianism. We see it as a threat. Still, Alice and I both like Greg. He doesn't seem evil to us. He seems kind.
My subject, then, is Christian nationalism—why people like Greg embrace it and how people like Alice (and like me) might respond critically but lovingly, with an emphasis on relationships not shaming. In many circles that I inhabit, almost all "liberal" by Greg's definition, Christian nationalism is evil, pure and simple, and any hint of love, even for people who embrace it, is out of the question. It can seem blasphemous to say anything nice about a Christian nationalist. It is as evil to us "liberals" as is liberalism to many people like Greg. But as a Christian I just can't see shutting out people. If God loves everybody, God loves Greg, too, and I should do the same. It's not hard. Like I said, he's a kind man.
So what is Christian nationalism? Here I follow the lead of Nilay Saiya, Associate Professor of Public Policy and Global Affairs at Nanyang Technological University in Singapore. I include a talk given by him below, given at Harvard University, in conversation with David N. Hempton, Harvard University Distinguished Service Professor and Alonzo L. McDonald Family Professor of Evangelical Theological Studies.
Saiya, a scholar of religion and global politics, is the author of Weapon of Peace: How Religious Liberty Combats Terrorism (Cambridge University Press, 2018) and The Global Politics of Jesus: A Christian Case for Church-State Separation (Oxford University Press, 2022). His research, along with the broader academic literature on Christian nationalism, informs the definitions, descriptions, and analyses that follow.
Underlying my approach is a theological presupposition true to the spirit of process theology: God is a God of love, dwelling in all hearts as an inwardly felt lure to love and care for others, to create communities of care, and to leave no one out. Like other process theologians, I don't think the future is known in advance by God, and that today there are various possibilities for how the world unfolds. I'm hoping for a world that Alice would like, and that is revealed, politics aside, in the kindness of Greg.