​
The Ivory-Billed Woodpecker Gone Forever

Apocalypse Fatigue Unabated

Own the Despair
Ivory-billed woodpeckers filmed in Louisiana in 1935, when the birds were already rare. Despite pleas from conservationists and wildlife officials, the area was later logged by the Chicago Mill and Lumber.  Company.CreditCredit...Arthur A. Allen/Macaulay Library at the Cornell Lab of Ornithology.


Sound of the Ivory Billed  Woodpecker
​

From the NY Times, September 29, 2021

The ivory-billed woodpecker, which birders have been seeking in the bayous of Arkansas, is gone forever, according to federal officials. So is the Bachman’s warbler, a yellow-breasted songbird that once migrated between the Southeastern United States and Cuba. The song of the Kauai O’o, a Hawaiian forest bird, exists only on recordings. And there is no longer any hope for several types of freshwater mussels that once filtered streams and rivers from Georgia to Illinois.

In all, 22 animals and one plant should be declared extinct and removed from the endangered species list, federal wildlife officials announced on Wednesday.

The announcement could also offer a glimpse of the future. It comes amid a worsening global biodiversity crisis that threatens a million species with extinction, many within decades. Human activities like farming, logging, mining and damming take habitat from animals and pollute much of what’s left. People poach and overfish. Climate change adds new peril.
“Each of these 23 species represents a permanent loss to our nation’s natural heritage and to global biodiversity,” said Bridget Fahey, who oversees species classification for the Fish and Wildlife Service. “And it’s a sobering reminder that extinction is a consequence of human-caused environmental change.”



280 billion songbirds lost.
My grief is complete.


A Poem by David DeBus after reading The Uninhabitable Earth

​

In his new book The Uninhabitable Earth: Life After Warming, David Wallace-Wells explores how climate change will impact not just the planet, but human lives – including how a five degree increase in temperatures would make parts of the planet unsurvivable.

“The more I learned about the science the deeper I got into it… the more scared I was,” he admits, “and from where I sat as a journalist the importance of telling that story so that other people have the same reaction have the same response.
​
Paradoxically, though he has only been writing about it for a few years, Wallace-Wells has found climate change to invigorate him as a storyteller. “It's an epic saga,” he says. “It's the kind of thing that we only used to see in mythology and theology. We really do have the fate of the world and the species in our hands.”


I Was A Friend
T’ang Dynasty Recollections
​

I was a friend of Li P’ai 
who wandered drunkenly
among heaven-ordained
green grasses, earth-rammed walls
saw swans overhead
and did not shout at them
heard the clatter of geese congealing
at the edge of the lake
in the falling light
like the geese in my grandfather’s lake
who pecked at us as children
 
280 billion songbirds already absent this year 2020
 
My brother says the T’ang Dynasty is one of two
times when the Japanese let foreign influences enter
before the modern era: Buddism and Chinese writing 
 
and now “stars shine on white bones’ 
it is two hundred years from now
and my grief is complete, my joy is benumbed
my failure to do absolutely everything
to stop our species-death preceded
by enormities of distress and cruelty
I just could not feel enough grief
for it to stay real at every moment to me
 

David DeBus, January 5, 2019, The Grove, Scripps Ranch Inspired by The Uninhabitable Earth: After Global Warming by David Wallace-Weeks.  Li P'ai is sometimes transcribed as Li Bai.  The third stanza is an aside from his brother, noting that, before the modern era, Japan permitted both Buddhism and the writing of Chinese characters to enter from this fertile dynasty.  The line "stars shine on white poems" comes from from Under Heaven by Guy Gavriel Kay.

The Sounds of a Dove

Birds After Rain

The Sounds of Geese Flying

Meadowlark



​Apocalypse Fatigue:
​A Role for Poetry 
​

Many people suffer from apocalypse fatigue around climate change.  It's too big, too abstract, and too much. 

​Click here for an essay by Norwegian Parliament representative Per Espen Stoknes on how to move past it.  He recommends reframing the issue in three ways.  Here's an excerpt.
​
"More than 80 percent of all news and mainstream media play up the issue of doomsday or catastrophe. From psychological research, we know that if you overdo the threat of catastrophe, you make people feel fear or guilt or a combination. But these two emotions are passive. They make people disconnect and avoid the topic rather than engage with it.

​There are three main frames that seem to create more engagement and work much better than catastrophe framings or other negative framings.

One framing involves speaking about climate change as a health issue concerning people we care about—our families, our children. We don’t want respiratory disease, so we all want clean air. The second is a safety or insurance framing. It’s about being prepared or ready in case something goes in the wrong direction—a risk management approach, that speaks to business/financial people. They work actively and professionally with risk and understand the need to insure. Finally, we should speak about opportunities for smarter cities, smarter buildings, better food sources, smarter energy systems and transportation systems, and all the opportunities that empowerment from these technologies gives us for better lives.
​
If we are able to reframe the climate issue this way in our society’s discourse, there is less fear and guilt attached to it—more a sense of “collective efficacy” or the idea that we can do something together as a society. Now, this deep reframing of the issue takes time—it’s different than simply having a slogan or a new news headline. But reframing impacts how people feel about and perceive the issue."

I appreciate these forms of reframing, but also appreciate the whole-hearted, full-bodied despair expressed in David Debus' poem.  There is something cleansing and purging about owning up to despair.  Something honest about guilt and hopelessness.  In the spiritual alphabet of humanity as developed by Frederic and Mary Ann Brussat in Spirituality and Practice, this honesty is a dimension of "owning the shadow."
​
The spiritual practice of shadow encourages us to make peace with those parts of ourselves that we find to be despicable, unworthy, and embarrassing — our anger, jealousy, pride, selfishness, violence, and other "evil deeds." In Christianity, shadow aspects show up as the seven deadly sins. Muslims talk about nafs as our lower selves, and Buddhists refer to negative emanations of mind. Societies and cultures also have dark sides.
​
We need poems of despair, such as offered by David DeBus, to help us own the shadow. 

And yet Debus would not have written his poem in the first place if he didn't carry within his heart a lingering sense that something can be done, not to avoid climate change, but to reduce its damage to whatever extent possible.  The lament "I could not feel enough grief" looks to the past.  But the lifting up of the model of the great Daoist poet, Li P'ai, "who wandered drunkenly among heaven-ordained green grasses, earth-rammed walls, and saw swans overhead," while ostensibly recalling a distant past, also functions as what process theologians call a "lure for feeling."  And lures come from the existential future, as a beckoning of what can be, even if only in the past.   As I read the poem, I cannot help but wish for wild swans overhead and the calling of geese.   I could not have thus wished, had it not been for the lament.  The hope depends on the contrast.  It comes only within and alongside the lament.

Eliza Barclay and Umair Irfan speak of Ten Ways to reduce the impact of climate change.  Cannot we also add an eleventh way?  Own the despair.  Acknowledge the guilt.  Experience the helplessness -- and then write a poem.  Let the poem be a ritual of honesty and also, in some quiet way, hope for some kind of salvage, however modest compared to the richness of the bio-spiritual world as we've known it.


​Eleven Ways to Reduce the
Impact of Climate Change 

​1) Price carbon emissions
2) Subsidize clean energy, and end subsidies for dirty energy
3) Close coal plants, and cut off the fossil fuel supply in other ways
4) Electrify everything and get more efficient
5) Invest in innovation
6) End production and sales of cars, trucks, and buses that run on fossil fuels
7) Require “zero deforestation” supply chains
8) Keep aging nuclear plants running
9) Discourage meat and dairy consumption, encourage plant-based diets
10) Remove carbon dioxide from the atmosphere
11) Write poems, tell stories, sing songs
 
Open Horizons